How can someone be a biology student without accepting the theory of evolution?
I accept it, but I don't understand how someone can be a dedicated biological science student without accepting this. Isn't the basis of modern biology centered around evolution (genetics)?
I bring this question up because I remember during the beginning of the semester some guy came to my bio lecture and a gave a short promotion of a presentation. He and his group were going to have on a presentation showing that evolutionary theory is a farce and use some type of pseudo-science to back up creationism. Most of the class laughed out loud at this but some people believed him.
How can someone be a biology student without accepting the theory of evolution?
Not saying that I don't accept it, but I don't understand how someone can be a dedicated biological science student without accepting this. Isn't the basis of modern biology centered around evolution (genetics)?
I bring this question up because I remember during the beginning of the semester some guy came to my bio lecture and a gave a short promotion of a presentation. He and his group were going to have on a presentation showing that evolutionary theory is a farce and use some type of pseudo-science to back up creationism. Most of the class laughed out loud at this but some people believed him.
I have a friend who's unsure about it. She's not crazy, she just has an issue thinking that all the mutations, etc, worked out so well (I think, we don't really discuss it much). Kinda makes sense, actually. She's not a creationist, I don't think, but questions how everything could have happened out of chance, even with x billion years to go.
Stop thinking so narrowly. Besides, biology is a huge field. Not everything needs to deal with the theory, or be taught through that spectrum.
I could ask you how a a nursing student could believe in euthanasia - isn't their whole career centered around saving life?
/avoids History and WWII reference
Last edited by britb : 04-18-2011 at 09:41 PM.
04-18-2011 at 09:42 PM
#4
Chevalier
Elite Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 965
Thanked:
59 Times
Liked:
203 Times
haha i went to see that lecture simply to amuse my self......it was TOTAL BULLS***...the guy had no clue what he was talking about....had had some college degree in eng or something.....and used outdated txt books to source his arguments....his arugments were also complete fallacies ...honestly it was sop pathetic lol..
though the wierdest part was that there were like middle aged-old adults there and some were taking notes as if they were going to go and use his arugments to show off or w.e --- sad -_-
best part was at the end this dude from one of my bio classes just started to tare apart his arguments and he got so flustered and tried to avoid the questionslol epic fail
__________________
~ moksa - liberation from mundane existence ~
04-18-2011 at 09:45 PM
#5
doppelganger
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 235
Thanked:
19 Times
Liked:
65 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by krup92
haha i went to see that lecture simply to amuse my self......it was TOTAL BULLS***...the guy had no clue what he was talking about....had had some college degree in eng or something.....and used outdated txt books to source his arguments....his arugments were also complete fallacies ...honestly it was sop pathetic lol..
though the wierdest part was that there were like middle aged-old adults there and some were taking notes as if they were going to go and use his arugments to show off or w.e --- sad -_-
best part was at the end this dude from one of my bio classes just started to tare apart his arguments and he got so flustered and tried to avoid the questionslol epic fail
lol i was gonna go just for fun as well but then i forgot about it.
04-18-2011 at 09:52 PM
#6
doppelganger
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 235
Thanked:
19 Times
Liked:
65 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by britb
I have a friend who's unsure about it. She's not crazy, she just has an issue thinking that all the mutations, etc, worked out so well (I think, we don't really discuss it much). Kinda makes sense, actually. She's not a creationist, I don't think, but questions how everything could have happened out of chance, even with x billion years to go.
Stop thinking so narrowly. Besides, biology is a huge field. Not everything needs to deal with the theory, or be taught through that spectrum.
I could ask you how a a nursing student could believe in euthanasia - isn't their whole career centered around saving life?
/avoids History and WWII reference
I am not thinking narrowly, evolution is a theory. As a science student I believe that every theory should be challenged, nothing should be blindly "believed", as you put. But it is the best we have so far so it must be accepted until something better comes along.
Also, one does not "believe" in a theory, you can choose to either accept it or not accept it. As well, euthanasia is not a theory. You can find euthanasia unethical but you can't say that evolution is "unethical".
04-18-2011 at 09:53 PM
#7
RyanC
Elite Member
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 5,014
Thanked:
406 Times
Liked:
2,312 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by britb
I have a friend who's unsure about it. She's not crazy, she just has an issue thinking that all the mutations, etc, worked out so well (I think, we don't really discuss it much). Kinda makes sense, actually. She's not a creationist, I don't think, but questions how everything could have happened out of chance, even with x billion years to go.
What biology specialization is she in?
Quote:
Originally Posted by britb
Stop thinking so narrowly. Besides, biology is a huge field. Not everything needs to deal with the theory, or be taught through that spectrum.
I agree that there are some discipline paths that are possible without needing to learn it, but it encompasses most of biology.
Quote:
Originally Posted by britb
I could ask you how a a nursing student could believe in euthanasia - isn't their whole career centered around saving life?
/avoids History and WWII reference
Nursing is based around patient care; respecting people on the grounds of informed consent, as well as letting people make their own decision.
/refutation to random irrelevant analogy
04-18-2011 at 09:57 PM
#8
britb
Mr.Spock is not dazzled.
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 1,630
Thanked:
86 Times
Liked:
611 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by ms92
I am not thinking narrowly, evolution is a theory. As a science student I believe that every theory should be challenged, nothing should be blindly "believed", as you put. But it is the best we have so far so it must be accepted until something better comes along.
Also, one does not "believe" in a theory, you can either accept it or not accept it. As well, euthanasia is not a theory. You can find euthanasia unethical but you can't say evolution is unethical.
"how can a biology student not agree with evolution" is pretty narrow to me. You're making the stipulation that any competent biology student must abscirbe to the theory, otherwise is does not make sense.
Accept a theory and believe a theory are the same. I accept a theory because I believe, for the time being at least, is explanation of an event is adequate. Don't try to make a semantic argument in place of a real one.
Euthanasia was simply to demonstrate people can have different beliefs, even if they seem to run counter to their degree/career/whatever, and still function perfectly fine. Maybe she doesn't agree with the practice, but she has to know procedures, protocols around it, and may need to assist with a patient one day.
Last edited by britb : 04-18-2011 at 10:00 PM.
04-18-2011 at 09:59 PM
#9
britb
Mr.Spock is not dazzled.
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 1,630
Thanked:
86 Times
Liked:
611 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by RyanC
What biology specialization is she in?
I agree that there are some discipline paths that are possible without needing to learn it, but it encompasses most of biology.
Nursing is based around patient care; respecting people on the grounds of informed consent, as well as letting people make their own decision.
/refutation to random irrelevant analogy
She's in Life Sci, but considers herself a biology student.
I'm not saying you do need to learn or know it, just that you don't need to necessarily believe it/accept it.
04-18-2011 at 10:04 PM
#10
waldo92
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 253
Thanked:
11 Times
Liked:
104 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by britb
I have a friend who's unsure about it. She's not crazy, she just has an issue thinking that all the mutations, etc, worked out so well (I think, we don't really discuss it much). Kinda makes sense, actually. She's not a creationist, I don't think, but questions how everything could have happened out of chance, even with x billion years to go.
Stop thinking so narrowly. Besides, biology is a huge field. Not everything needs to deal with the theory, or be taught through that spectrum.
I could ask you how a a nursing student could believe in euthanasia - isn't their whole career centered around saving life?
/avoids History and WWII reference
if she thinks that the idea that all life and its diversity came through chance is absurd, I agree, if she thinks that evolution is a theory that proposes that, then she either misunderstands evolution or, much more probably, purposely distorts it in her mind for religious reasons - evolution, at it's core, is a really simple idea.
with that said, it's an incredibly powerful idea - biology is a huge field, but evolution is the theory that completely explains why and how ALL life is the way it is, and as such, it's utterly central to the field. quoting some guy i'm too lazy to look up - "nothing in biology makes sense, except in the light of evolution".
i'm hoping that "friend" isn't you
04-18-2011 at 10:09 PM
#11
Reda
Elite Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 526
Thanked:
63 Times
Liked:
274 Times
i need to see this
04-18-2011 at 10:09 PM
#12
doppelganger
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 235
Thanked:
19 Times
Liked:
65 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by britb
"how can a biology student not agree with evolution" is pretty narrow to me. You're making the stipulation that any competent biology student must abscirbe to the theory, otherwise is does not make sense.
But it is true that biology as whole does not make sense without the basis of evolutionary theory.
Also, "accepting" means to take something as a fact while "believing in" refers to using something as a philosophy/guide to life.
04-18-2011 at 10:10 PM
#13
Tailsnake
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,404
Thanked:
170 Times
Liked:
453 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by ms92
I am not thinking narrowly, evolution is a theory. As a science student I believe that every theory should be challenged, nothing should be blindly "believed", as you put. But it is the best we have so far so it must be accepted until something better comes along.
Also, one does not "believe" in a theory, you can choose to either accept it or not accept it. As well, euthanasia is not a theory. You can find euthanasia unethical but you can't say that evolution is "unethical".
Sorry to be nitpicky, but this point always annoys me:
Evolution is a FACT, Natural Selection is a THEORY
People often conflate the two, but evolution is an observable process; we can witness it happen and we can induce it in lab environments. The theory is the mechanism behind this change. Gravity is in the same boat (i.e. Gravity is a fact, Newtonian Gravity, General Relativity, Entropic Gravity, etc. are Theories)
Sorry to be nitpicky, but this point always annoys me:
Evolution is a FACT, Natural Selection is a THEORY
People often conflate the two, but evolution is an observable process; we can witness it happen and we can induce it in lab environments. The theory is the mechanism behind this change. Gravity is in the same boat (i.e. Gravity is a fact, Newtonian Gravity, General Relativity, Entropic Gravity, etc. are Theories)
McMaster University News and Information, Student-run Community, with topics ranging from Student Life, Advice, News, Events, and General Help.
Notice: The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the student(s) who authored the content. The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by McMaster University or the MSU (McMaster Students Union). Being a student-run community, all articles and discussion posts on MacInsiders are unofficial and it is therefore always recommended that you visit the official McMaster website for the most accurate up-to-date information.